Well, Starsport fired up a copy of FIFA 12 and took a look through the players’ stats on the game.
Back then, Michail Antonio was about to set out on loan to League One side Colchester United and an 18-year-old Manuel Lanzini had just returned to River Plate after a loan spell at Fluminense.
So what were the ratings of the Hammers‘ players?
Click through the gallery above to find out. We’ve also included the rating they could potentially reach in career mode.